POWER-UP Air Purifier 실행 로그

verdict: FLAG

[orchestrator] processing: https://www.red-dot.org/project/power-up-air-purifier-63638
[orchestrator] dataDir: /home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/data
[orchestrator] outputDir: /home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out
[orchestrator] card version: v1 (mapToCardV1 + reviewCardV1)
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:52:41.170Z","step":"fetch_page","status":"start","url":"https://www.red-dot.org/project/power-up-air-purifier-63638","sourceType":"red_dot_award"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:52:42.103Z","step":"fetch_page","status":"done","htmlLength":55928}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:52:42.103Z","step":"parse","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:52:42.130Z","step":"parse","status":"done","title":"POWER-UP Air Purifier","imageCount":3}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:52:42.130Z","step":"map_to_card","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:05.070Z","step":"map_to_card","status":"done","product":"POWER-UP Air Purifier","brand":"Coway"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:05.071Z","step":"save_draft","status":"start","cardId":"Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:05.078Z","step":"save_draft","status":"done","draftPath":"/home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out/_drafts/사례_Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier.draft.md"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:05.078Z","step":"fetch_assets","status":"start","imageCount":3}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:06.936Z","step":"fetch_assets","status":"done","imageDir":"/home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/data/이미지/Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier","savedImages":3,"failedImages":0}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:56:06.936Z","step":"review_card","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:57:28.968Z","step":"review_card","status":"done","verdict":"FLAG"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:57:28.968Z","step":"save_final","status":"start","cardId":"Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:57:28.974Z","step":"save_final","status":"done","cardPath":"/home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out/사례_Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier.md"}
[orchestrator] verdict: FLAG
[orchestrator] saved: /home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out/사례_Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier.md
{
  "cardId": "Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier",
  "cardPath": "/home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out/사례_Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier.md",
  "draftPath": "/home/towner/piix-design-scrape-runs/fresh-2026-06-05-night-claude-idc1/out/_drafts/사례_Coway_POWER-UP_Air_Purifier.draft.md",
  "verdict": "FLAG",
  "issues": [
    {
      "field": "source_documents[0].speaker_role",
      "type": "speaker_role",
      "detail": "S1은 Red Dot 페이지로 브랜드 설명과 jury 심사평을 함께 포함하는데 문서 단위 speaker_role이 \"brand\"로만 표기됨. passage/quote 단위 구분은 대체로 맞음."
    },
    {
      "field": "summary.one_line",
      "type": "추론과잉",
      "detail": "원문은 수직·수평 라인이 통풍구와 먼지센서를 은폐한다고 했고, 손잡이는 닫힌 상태에서 매끄럽게 통합된다고만 함. 라인으로 손잡이까지 감춘다는 표현은 과함."
    },
    {
      "field": "knowledge.사용_맥락.사용_상황, knowledge.경험_가치.사용자_효과, knowledge.형태_전략.*",
      "type": "정보없음",
      "detail": "values가 비어 있는데 source_label이 \"원문 추출\" 또는 \"원문+추론\", confidence가 중간/높음, evidence_ids가 붙어 있는 항목들이 있음. 비어 있는 값이면 정보 없음 처리와 일관되어야 함."
    },
    {
      "field": "knowledge.경험_가치.핵심_가치, design_logic.사용자_경험",
      "type": "confidence",
      "detail": "\"절제\", \"위화감 없이\" 같은 표현은 원문 직접 표현이라기보다 stringent/monolithic/uniform에서의 해석이므로 \"원문 추출\"보다는 \"원문+추론\"이 적절함."
    },
    {
      "field": "design_logic.주요_디자인_선택",
      "type": "speaker_role",
      "detail": "\"모놀리식·균일 구조\"는 jury 인용(Q5/E5)에 근거한 표현인데 actor가 \"브랜드\"로만 되어 있고 evidence_ids에도 E5가 빠져 있음."
    },
    {
      "field": "quote_snippets",
      "type": "quote",
      "detail": "각 quote는 짧지만 Q1-Q5가 원문 설명 대부분을 조각내어 담고 있어 원문 복사 비중이 다소 높음."
    }
  ],
  "notes": "핵심 사실과 참조 존재성은 대체로 맞지만, 일부 source_label·actor·confidence가 과하고 빈 필드 메타데이터가 불일치해 FLAG."
}