YAASA Desk Four 실행 로그

verdict: FAIL

> piix-design-scraper@0.1.0 scrape
> node src/orchestrator/index.js https://www.red-dot.org/project/yaasa-desk-four-63372

[orchestrator] processing: https://www.red-dot.org/project/yaasa-desk-four-63372
[orchestrator] dataDir: /Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/data
[orchestrator] outputDir: /Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out
[orchestrator] card version: v1 (mapToCardV1 via Codex + reviewCardV1)
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:18:36.383Z","step":"fetch_page","status":"start","url":"https://www.red-dot.org/project/yaasa-desk-four-63372","sourceType":"red_dot_award"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:18:37.521Z","step":"fetch_page","status":"done","htmlLength":56335}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:18:37.521Z","step":"parse","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:18:37.531Z","step":"parse","status":"done","title":"YAASA Desk Four","imageCount":3}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:18:37.532Z","step":"map_to_card","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:21.132Z","step":"map_to_card","status":"done","product":"YAASA Desk Four","brand":"YAASA GmbH"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:21.134Z","step":"save_draft","status":"start","cardId":"YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:21.138Z","step":"save_draft","status":"done","draftPath":"/Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out/_drafts/사례_YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four.draft.md"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:21.138Z","step":"fetch_assets","status":"start","imageCount":3}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:43.571Z","step":"fetch_assets","status":"done","imageDir":"/Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/data/이미지/YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four","savedImages":2,"failedImages":1}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:20:43.572Z","step":"review_card","status":"start"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:21:00.976Z","step":"review_card","status":"done","verdict":"FAIL"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:21:00.976Z","step":"save_final","status":"start","cardId":"YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four"}
[orchestrator] {"ts":"2026-06-05T12:21:00.977Z","step":"save_final","status":"done","cardPath":"/Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out/사례_YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four.md"}
[orchestrator] verdict: FAIL
[orchestrator] saved: /Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out/사례_YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four.md
{
  "cardId": "YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four",
  "cardPath": "/Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out/사례_YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four.md",
  "draftPath": "/Users/jun/piix/.claude/worktrees/design-knowledge/jun-research/디자인저장소/v2/samples/fresh-2026-06-05-night/codex/out/_drafts/사례_YAASA_GmbH_YAASA_Desk_Four.draft.md",
  "verdict": "FAIL",
  "issues": [
    {
      "field": "evidence.E5.quote_id",
      "type": "참조",
      "detail": "E5는 quote_id를 Q4로 참조하지만 quote 내용은 Q4의 'two positions can be stored'가 아니라 원문 3문장의 'using the Desk Four from several sides'에 해당한다. 존재하는 quote와 evidence 내용이 불일치한다."
    },
    {
      "field": "source_passages.P1/P3.speaker_role",
      "type": "speaker_role",
      "detail": "Red Dot 원문에서 P1, P3는 브랜드 발화로 명시되지 않았고 플랫폼 설명에 가까워 brand로 단정하기는 애매하다."
    },
    {
      "field": "knowledge.경험_가치.브랜드_경험",
      "type": "정보없음",
      "detail": "values가 비어 있는데 source_label은 '원문+추론', confidence는 '중간'으로 되어 있어 공백 값 처리와 라벨이 맞지 않는다."
    }
  ],
  "notes": "대부분의 내용은 원문에서 도출 가능하지만, evidence 참조 불일치가 있어 폐기 기준에 해당한다."
}